As President Obama takes office, the whole nation is moving into a new generation. Barack Obama is the first Gen X President in US history. Garrison Keillor, on Prairie Home Companion, did a wonderful sketch about this, where Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and John McCain are all wondering where their generation has gone, and what the future will hold.
Each generation has a different vision of society and of leadership. If we want to pass on the torch, we must understand ourselves, understand those who come after, and respect the differences.
If we want organizations – businesses or not-for-profit groups – to survive, we must pass on the torch. How do we do it?
Views of Truth, Authority, and Social Involvement
Two factors make the generational transition of leadership, especially in not-for-profit organization, difficult:
First, each generation has its own view of truth, authority, and social involvement. These views arise from childhood experience, both at home, and of the larger political and social sphere.
From 1900 through WWII, patriotism and respect for authority was high, and the army could recruit with a poster of Uncle Sam pointing a finger and saying, “I want you for the US Army.”
The silent generation remembered, or learned about, their parent’s sacrifices in WW II, and for Korea and Vietnam, the draft was still in place. Until the middle of the Vietnam war, patriotism was still strong. The US Army could recruit with a call to patriotism plus, as individualism increased, commitment to help people improve through training in the military plus education with the GI bill.
The Baby Boomers came into adulthood in the 1960s, and the Vietnam War and the assassinations of the Kennedys and Martin Luther King, Jr. cast doubt on the authority of government institutions. But belief in higher values was still clear. Even if society was not perfect, its ideals were inspiring. People could be called to join organizations – mainstream or protest – in support of ideals. One of those ideals was teamwork, and “Join the People who Joined the Army” was an effective call to action. The view of the world was large, and Life and Look were the magazines of the day.
Most of us in leadership positions these days think this way. And we are puzzled with how to help our younger colleagues see the way we do.
They won’t. Their experience and values are different. The last historical moment we faced was Watergate, where justice did win out over a President committing crimes. After that, with one scandal after another, the era of spin began, and Gen X and Gen Y children do not trust anyone who claims to hold a vision or have a mission.
Individualism is on the increase. Teamwork is no longer an important value. The army can’t use it to recruit: It has moved away from teamwork, first to “Be all that you can be” and then to “An Army of One.” Life and Look were replaced first by People, then by Us, and, most recently, by Self magazine.
Individualism is not a bad thing. Our society, as a free society, will continue to seek the balance between social involvement and individual expression and fulfillment. But valuing individuals is one thing. Being unable to function in teams is something else.
This brings up the second change from one generation of workers to the next. Studies show that basic emotional intelligence skills – such as anger management and the empathy that makes teamwork possible – are decreasing in the US every ten years.
This failure of teamwork arises from the collapse of the family, as well as other social factors. Past generations grew up in a clan of grandparents, uncles and aunts, and cousins. The 1950s brought in the isolated nuclear family; and children learned fewer social skills. Since the 1980s, most children live with only one parent. Even children with two parents often find that both must work. Children fend for themselves when parents are absent, and some must even struggle to survive when their parents are not functional – suffering from illness, alcoholism, or drug or gambling addictions. These factors are a major aspect of the profile for Gen X, and even more for Gen Y. The result is not so much that they prefer individualism, it’s that many in Gen X and Gen Y never had a healthy experience of community.
The Solution: Individual Mentoring
And yet, the human needs for society and inspiration never go away. They are only frustrated. So we can help our Gen X and Gen Y colleagues by giving them the inspiration and structure that they reject, but also want and need.
The best way to do this is to introduce values in the context of what these people already know. If they are in business, why should it be honest business? What are the values of their particular profession? If they are caring for their own children, why are love and attention important, and how do they do them? Asking questions like these, and providing your own personal answers, without claiming to be an authority, is wonderful guidance that we Baby Boomers can offer Gen X and Gen Y. In my experience, people in Gen X and Gen Y become strongly loyal to those who claim not to know the truth, but to be seeking to discover truth and make life better.
The best organizational tool for this is individual mentoring into useful roles within the organization. Help younger leaders see that they can do good work, survive and thrive, and contribute. Help them see that who they are and what they have to offer are not separate. Help them see that teamwork, honesty, and other key values are actually part of a successful and happy life as an individual, and as part of a team or family.
Making Mentoring Work
Mentoring works because the personal experience of a trustworthy person touches us deeply. This goes to the root of the development of emotional intelligence, where experiential learning can undo childhood conditioning. A child who learns not to trust must learn trust through relationship with a trustworthy colleague or friend.
It is a huge commitment. Being a mentor challenges us to become more reliable, to manage our time better, to communicate well and make things work better than we have in the past.
Being a mentor means growing in leadership, and growing as a person. And helping someone else do the same thing. This is truly Leading From Within, growing, and helping others grow with us.
Mentoring meets the needs of the individualist, while also showing them that the fully happy and healthy individual receives the torch that is passed on, and carries it forward, a leader and light to new generations.